Europe's suicide (com)pact

The draft of the fiscal compact, hailed as a masterpiece by Angela Merkel, was released yesterday (see here). Note article 3.1.a. which says that "the budgetary position of the general government shall be balanced or in surplus." This is more stringent than the old Stability and Growth Pact (SGP) that the fiscal compact supersedes. The consequences of fiscal austerity are already dramatic, and the notion that more of the same can actually have a positive effect is simple madness.


  1. Every countries' budget in surplus? Astonishing idiocy .... that's like saying everybody should be part of the 1%!

  2. Yep. And it also enshrines the doctrine of expansionary contraction since it says that to "foster budgetary discipline through a fiscal compact" will lead to "sustainable growth, employment" and social bliss. A country may have a structural defict of 1% only if debt to GDP is below 60%. SGP on steroids.

  3. However, 6 of 7 EEUU crisis were preceded by budget surplus...
    Shouldn't they have unemployment targets, like EEUU during Okun's times?

  4. Booms generate surpluses, since revenue goes up. It would be more important to check whether government discretionary spending was being reduced before the recessions, in which case one could claim that, at least in part, contractionary fiscal policy was part of the causes of the recession. There is little doubt I think that in Greece now, for example, fiscal policy is contractionary. The fiscal compact will make things worse.

  5. Of course. What I was intending to mention is that this surplus obsession is unfounded both empirically an theoretically


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

A brief note on Venezuela and the turn to the right in Latin America

Back of the envelope calculation: BNDES lending and the Marshall Plan