Showing posts with label Comparative Advantage. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Comparative Advantage. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 7, 2026

Anwar Shaikh (1945–2026)

 
With Anwar and Costas Lapavitsas at a conference in Tulsa

I was very saddened to hear of Anwar Shaikh’s passing. Anwar was one of the most important Marxian economists of his generation, perhaps together with David Gordon and Duncan Foley, at least in the US, both his colleagues at the New School.* He spent his career defending and developing the surplus approach in the broadest sense, against both mainstream economics and much of heterodox economics.

I disagreed with him on many things. On the theory of value, on Marx’s law of the tendency of the rate of profit to fall, on Say’s Law, and particularly on the determination of real exchange rates and purchasing power parity. In fact, an entire chapter of my PhD dissertation was devoted to his theory of exchange rates, which I regarded then, and still regard, as the main Marxist approach to the subject. The thesis was also critical of both mainstream and Post Keynesian theories of exchange rate determination, btw. I also disagreed with him on a number of policy questions, including the causes of inflation in many Latin American countries. These were not minor differences.

I also think that some of his work was creative and important in many respects, and closer to my views (not just issues of conflictive distribution associated to the surplus approach). His critique of comparative advantage influenced my understanding of the topic (also here). His work on the welfare state is something I often cite and use in classes. And his paper on the humbug production function was perhaps his most famous work.

Whether I agreed or disagreed with him, that never diminished my respect for him. Anwar was intellectually honest, genuinely pluralistic, and always willing to engage seriously with arguments with which he disagreed. That is rarer than it should be in economics. He believed deeply that alternative traditions in political economy had to be developed rigorously and confronted with both theory and evidence.

His work kept alive a broad classical and Marxian tradition centered on production, distribution, competition and the social surplus. The questions he insisted on asking were important ones, and his willingness to argue about them openly made heterodox economics better. He will be greatly missed.

PS: Bard College has an archive with his papers that is worth exploring.

* Sam Bowles would be another possible name, but I don't think he considers himself a Marxist anymore (and he might be right). I would also not put analytical or post-modern Marxists at this level. These are obviously debatable views.

Wednesday, March 16, 2016

Free trade and Portuguese decline

Last weekend, as a result of Brad DeLong's post on free trade, we had a brief Twitter exchange. He had suggested that the Heckscher-Ohlin (HO) model* implies gains from trade associated to comparative advantage. He went further and suggested, after I implied that the Methuen Treaty between England and Portugal had not been favorable to the latter, that Portugal had indeed benefited greatly from free trade.

It is important to note, before we get to Portugal, that the HO model, which is a direct application of marginalist theory of value to international trade, arguing that specialization depends on relative scarcity, with countries exporting the goods that use intensively the factor of production that is abundant, is open to the capital debates critique, as shown by Ian Steedman long ago. So the HO model results lack generality, and it is NOT possible to guarantee gains of trade, as suggested by Brad. Actually, there should be no surprise that one finds paradoxes and problems, like the famous Leontief Paradox.

That does not mean that comparative advantage is conceptually wrong. The old Ricardian model does not have the problems of the HO model (Brad would have been on more solid logical grounds using this model). It is open to critiques of its use of the labor theory of value (LTV), but those can be dealt by the Sraffian reinterpretation of the LTV (for that, although not related to trade, go here). Note, however, that Ricardo's model presumes fixed levels of employment (not full employment, but given or constant) and no capital mobility. Anthony Brewer showed (subscription required) that in the Ricardian model, with capital mobility, producers would move to the country with lower costs, basically lower wages (exogenously given by classical authors), and absolute advantage would dominate trade patterns.

So what about trade between England and Portugal, you may ask. In part, the reason why Ricardo, a descendant of Portuguese jews that emigrated to Italy, the Netherlands and then to England, used the cloth-wine/England-Portugal example in his Principles, is because of the Methuen Treaty of 1703, a sort of free trade agreement. If one looks at income per capita (Table below using the Maddison data), one finds that Portugal was, by the time that follows its control of the trade routes to Asia (after Vasco da Gama reached India in 1498), slightly ahead of England, but by 1700, on the eve of the Treaty, it was considerably behind. Yet, by 1750, it seems that Portugal caugth up a bit, only to fall inexorably behind after that. By 1820, the income per capita in Portugal is less than half of the English.


So is there any truth to Brad's view that Portugal benefited from the free trade agreement, you may ask again. The point is that, the Iberian Union (1580-1640), when Portugal was governed by Spanish kings, and the loss of the Asian Empire (but not Brazil) was behind the Portuguese long term decline, which started way before the Methuen Treaty. Guns (and sails, Carlo Cipolla would add), not comparative advantage, were behind the rise and fall of the Portuguese empire in Asia.  The Dutch and then the English would come to dominate those trade routes. And the improvement in income per capita in the 18th century in Portugal can be ascribed to the discovery of gold in Brazil (a little aside, it is the combination of Brazilian gold, the Methuen Treaty, and the infamous mistake in the pricing of silver by Sir Isaac Newton that, arguably, put England on a Gold Standard). Free trade did not explain that.

So the Methuen Treaty by itself did not cause the ruin of Portugal. But it added to the problems associated to the loss of the Asian empire, and created patterns of specialization that did not lead to further technical change and economic development. Trade matters, because what one country produces and exports matters. Complex products with higher value added are more likely to lead to the incremental innovations that are behind the wealth of nations. You may call that increasing returns or cumulative causation. Trade agreements that ossify the production structure in sectors with low levels of technological dynamism lead to lower growth, and, as in any process with path dependency, failure breeds failure. Portugal, like England, needed managed trade, not 'free' trade.

* The model is often referred to as Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson (HOS), since Paul Samuelson was instrumental in formalizing the HO theorem and extending some of its results. Also, less frequently the model is referred to as Heckscher-Ohlin-Vanek (HOV), as done by Brad, since Jaroslav Vanek noted that trade of goods is indirect trade of factors of production, providing further extensions to the model.

Monday, November 16, 2015

Comparative Advantage and Capitalism

From CAPITALISM the documentary by Ilan Ziv. In this short clip a discussion of comparative advantage and its limitations, with Pascal Lamy, Robert Boyer and yours truly (many others in this chapter, including Geoff Hodgson and Ha-Joon Chang).

The Mexican secretary of finance that appears in the video is actually NOT talking about the Ricardian model of trade, which at least given its assumptions is logically correct, but about the neoclassical or Heckscher-Ohlin-Samuelson (HOS) model that has significant problems (see here).

I should note also that in my view Ricardo should not be seen as Robert Boyer suggests (not shown in the video above) as a precursor of mainstream neoclassical economics for his role in the development of formal models. Formal models can be marginalist or not, and actually Ricardo's ideas led to Marx. As I noted in my interview (in parts that do not appear in he documentary), Ricardo was the first economist to formalize the idea of a distributive conflict between capital and labor, once the Smithian notion of the adding up theory was criticized. I joke that contrary to Samuelson's view according to which Marx was a minor Ricardian, one should think of him as a major Ricardian. And in many other ways Ricardo's legacy has been misunderstood (without even discussing  Barro's Ricardian Equivalence).