On Economic Traditions and the Sociology of the Knowledge

 

Marx & Smith vs Weber & Bentham 

I often use Randall Collins’ book Four Sociological Traditions in my class discussions and in my own work on the history of economic ideas. Collins’ discussion of economics as the first social science is instructive about how disciplines become autonomous from other fields. Economics emerged earlier than the other social sciences as an independent discipline, in his account, because states had practical reasons to collect information about taxation, trade, population, and public finance. Mercantilism created a body of empirical and administrative knowledge, and later writers, starting with William Petty (he cites François Quesnay and then Adam Smith rather than Petty), transformed these concerns into a more systematic intellectual discipline. Economics was able to establish itself institutionally before sociology because it had both practical applications and a relatively clear object of study.

Collins then shows how economics became increasingly professionalized during the nineteenth century. There is an extensive literature on that (on the American case see Coats, 1988). Classical political economy initially developed partly outside the universities, especially in Britain. In Germany, however, economics became more firmly tied to state administration and university training (on the German Historical School see Kurz, 2016). Later, marginalism and neoclassical economics helped turn economics into a more abstract and specialized academic discipline. Collins’s broader point is that the content of economic theory cannot be separated entirely from the institutional settings in which economists worked.

For Collins, ideas are produced inside social networks and institutions. Intellectual change occurs when institutional spaces open up, when new professional roles become available, and when communities of scholars compete over problems, methods, and prestige. In that sense, the rise of the social sciences – economics and, more interestingly, sociology itself – is a sociological phenomenon. The community makes the discipline.

Read rest here.