Skip to main content

More on Italy: on Dean Bakers hypothesis

Dean Baker has suggested to Krugman that one reason for the lower productivity in Italy is that actual employment was higher before the euro, or if you prefer disguised unemployment was rampant. Then with the entry in the euro several workers that were not legally hired were, and as a result it only seems that productivity fell a lot. That is, it looks like a lot more workers are not doing that much more in terms of production, when in fact the actual increase in employment was not that large, and, hence, the fall in productivity not as big. Certainly an interesting possibility. Below the employment in Italy and in France compared (1970=100).
Note that, in fact, up to the 1980s employment grew faster in Italy than in France, and by the mid-1990s this trend was reversed. While it is true that in the late 1990s, with the euro, it seems that employment again grew faster in Italy (which may be due to Dean's suggestion), note that the proportional increase is relatively small (about 3.9% with respect to France from 2000 to 2006), and has reversed since the crisis. It seems that most of the fall in productivity is real, and caused by the fact that Italy grows less. Again, I think these reflects overly restrictive policies and reflects the well know regularity known as Kaldor-Verdoorn Law.


  1. Goddamnit! You can never win!

    I brought this to Baker's attention and aked him to pass it onto Krugman. Baker is probably right, to an extent. But still, as I pointed out with the same graphs I put on your last post, lower employment is driving lower gross capital formation and this in turn probably has a lagged effect on productivity.

    You can see that this has been the case in Italy since the major rise in unemployment in the 1980s if you look at the data:

    Baker agreed that the post-2008 slowdown was due to the KV Law, but I was trying to make the case that this was a far broader phenomena that could be shown to exist all over the place.

    1. Yes, but note that the increase in employment (which would result from Dean's hypothesis is not that big). So it is unlikely that productivity fell because output grew, but employment grew more. What actually happened is that growth was subdued in Italy. So the point remains that contractionary policies explain lack of growth and KV the slowdown in productivity.

  2. So what is the timeframe that the Kaldor-Verdoorn law is supposed to operate? I admit that I always thought of it as involving technological improvements embodied in the new investment spurred by high demand, and so was supposed to be an explanation of effects of demand on productivity over the medium-long term of decades. It would't apply to periods of just a few years since the capital stock is basically fixed over such periods.

    The equivalent short-term relationship is Okun's law. It's not clear to me how one distinguishes the two relationships (both demand-->output-->measured productivity) operationally and maybe even conceptually. But Okun's law might be more appropriate for periods of just a few years, no?

    1. Yes you are correct. Okun is the cyclical relation and KV is the trend. So the point is not really about the time period per se, since both cyclical and trend forces are always in action (I have a paper here that tries to separate the effects). As the trend in productivity clearly changes after the euro, so does the trend in output growth, while that is NOT the case with employment. So it seems that it is a trend caused by the change in the macro policy regime with the euro, and being a trend I would say it is the KV effect.

    2. Right, I think that's the strongest argument against Dean's view, that the productivity slowdown seems to take the form of a deceleration of output rather than acceleration of employment growth. Of course, one could always postulate that there is a causally independent slowdown in growth happening at the same time...


Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

What is the 'Classical Dichotomy'?

A few brief comments on Brexit and the postmortem of the European Union

Another end of the world is possible
There will be a lot of postmortems for the European Union (EU) after Brexit. Many will suggest that this was a victory against the neoliberal policies of the European Union. See, for example, the first three paragraphs of Paul Mason's column here. And it is true, large contingents of working class people, that have suffered with 'free-market' economics, voted for leaving the union. The union, rightly or wrongly, has been seen as undemocratic and responsible for the economics woes of Europe.

The problem is that while it is true that the EU leaders have been part of the problem and have pursued the neoliberal policies within the framework of the union, sometimes with treaties like the Fiscal Compact, it is far from clear that Brexit and the possible demise of the union, if the fever spreads to France, Germany and other countries with their populations demanding their own referenda, will lead to the abandonment of neoliberal policies. Aust…

A brief note on Venezuela and the turn to the right in Latin America

So besides the coup in Brazil (which was all but confirmed by the last revelations, if you had any doubts), and the electoral victory of Macri in Argentina, the crisis in Venezuela is reaching a critical level, and it would not be surprising if the Maduro administration is recalled, even though right now the referendum is not scheduled yet.

The economy in Venezuela has collapsed (GDP has fallen by about 14% or so in the last two years), inflation has accelerated (to three digit levels; 450% or so according to the IMF), there are shortages of essential goods, recurrent energy blackouts, and all of these aggravated by persistent violence. Contrary to what the press suggests, these events are not new or specific to left of center governments. Similar events occurred in the late 1980s, in the infamous Caracazo, when the fall in oil prices caused an external crisis, inflation, and food shortages, which eventually, after the announcement of a neoliberal economic package that included the i…