Sunday, June 14, 2026
Rod O’Donnell on Keynes and Liberal Socialism
Saturday, June 6, 2026
Milei is not Roca
Pablo Gerchunoff has an interesting interview in La Nación in which he suggests that Milei, like Roca (the Argentine Porfirio, for gringos that know something about Mexico), has seen a structural change in the Argentine economy and has been able to convert it into a political opportunity. In Roca’s case, the combination of railways and refrigerated shipping opened the possibility of the old agro-export model. In Milei’s case, Gerchunoff points to the new productive geography along Route 40, with mining and energy potential. The natural gas and oil of Vaca Muerta, the possibilities of lithium, the mining and energy resources of Patagonia and the northwest frontier.
There is something to the point. But the analogy, I think, is more misleading than illuminating. I also might add that it is striking that someone like Gerchunoff, who once admired what he saw as Alfonsín’s non-Peronist social-democratic model (something that I share), could now find historical promise in Milei.*
On the historical issue, it is clear that Roca's model was not similar to the current one. The so-called generation of 80 did talk the language of liberalism, but the construction of that economic model required a very active state. Military occupation, territorial incorporation, railways, ports, public credit, land policy, immigration policy, and a political regime designed to guarantee the conditions for accumulation. Free markets did not spontaneously build the agro-export economy. It was built by the state, often violently. The current government wants the epic of a new productive frontier without public works, without infrastructure, and without the political construction that made the old liberal order possible.
There is another problem. Much of the so-called Route 40 strategy depends on investments and institutional decisions that preceded Milei. Vaca Muerta did not fall from the sky in December 2023. Energy infrastructure, the development of shale production, and the reduction of energy imports are the result of previous policies and investments. Milei can try to appropriate the narrative, and he may even give excessive incentives to some sectors, like AI (see Milei's piece in the FT), through the RIGI and other measures (for an explanation of the investment regime go here). But the current improvement in the external sector is not evidence that chainsaw economics works. It is evidence that past public investment, together with favorable external conditions (and a lot of dollars from the IMF and the US Treasury), can temporarily improve the balance of payments.
This is also why the idea that Milei is an outsider was always implausible. As I have noted before, the economic team is not new. Caputo and Sturzenegger are not outsiders to Argentine economic policy. They were central to the Macri experiment, which led to the 2018 IMF agreement and the renewed dollar debt trap. Milei’s rhetoric is anti-caste, but the economic program is the old neoliberal package of fiscal austerity, deregulation, trade and financial liberalization, and external indebtedness. The dog may be new, but the fleas are not.
Gerchunoff is right to worry about the losers of creative destruction (not sure how much is being created). But here too the Roca analogy fails. Argentina today is not a sparse nineteenth-century frontier society organized around land, beef exports, and a small urban elite. It is a modern, urban, very unequal society with a large working class, a complex service sector, industrial remnants, public employment, pensions, universities, health systems, infrastructure needs, and a binding external constraint. You cannot tell workers in the so-called conurbano to wait until 2050 or move to Patagonia. That is not a transition strategy. And it is not even good politics.
Where I disagree more sharply with Gerchunoff is on the exchange rate. He suggests that if the central bank moved the dollar closer to the top of the band (a devaluation in Latin American usage), Milei would almost guarantee reelection. That seems wishful thinking. Milei’s only clear achievement has been the reduction of inflation from the very high levels reached after the exchange-rate jumps of 2023. But that stabilization was not caused by fiscal austerity as such. The fiscal shock caused recession and the persistence of Argentina stagnation since 2011. The stabilization of prices came mainly from controlling the exchange rate, with substantial external support. The initial maxi-devaluation in December 2023 doubled monthly inflation and produced the collapse of real wages. Another depreciation would risk repeating the same mechanism. Higher import costs, higher prices, lower real wages, weaker consumption, and renewed instability.
In a peripheral economy with a strong pass-through from the exchange rate to prices, depreciation is not a magic route to competitiveness. It is often contractionary and inflationary. It reduces real wages, worsens distributional conflict, raises the domestic cost of imported inputs, and may fail to generate exports to compensate for the contraction of domestic demand. The idea that a cheaper currency automatically solves the external constraint is another version of the same marginalist fantasy that relative prices are the main mechanism of adjustment. In Argentina, relative prices often adjust by generating a crisis. Note that he already has a positive external situation in the short run (in the long run, the next several governments will have to contend with much higher external debt obligations).
This does not mean that the current exchange rate regime is sustainable indefinitely. It probably is not. But the problem is not solved by devaluation. The problem is that the government is trying to stabilize a highly dollarized economy with negative interest rate differential, offering insufficient incentives to hold pesos, scarce reserves, external dependence, and a brutal recessionary adjustment. In those conditions, a depreciation may be less a solution than the beginning of the next round of instability.
The broader issue is that the nineteenth-century liberal model cannot be recreated in a twenty-first-century Argentina. Even the nineteenth-century liberal model was less liberal than its admirers pretend. Today, a development strategy would require public investment, infrastructure, industrial and technological policy, energy planning, external management, and institutions capable of integrating the losers of structural change. Milei has none of that. He has a chainsaw, a Twitter account, and the enthusiastic support of the same groups that benefited from previous failed neoliberal experiments.
Roca, for all the brutality and exclusions of his project, built a state capable of organizing a model of accumulation. Milei is dismantling state capacity while claiming to inaugurate a new era of material progress. The result may last long enough to win an election if external financing keeps arriving. But the logic of the model points, as before, toward a crash. Roca 'conquered' the desert, Milei is creating a productive one.
* If you read Spanish I highly recommend his book on Alfonsín.
Friday, August 15, 2025
The World Upsidedown: Progressives and the Return of the Victorian Policy Consensus

Eminent Victorian?
The complete shitshow that US trade policy has become has led to a paradoxical result. Many progressive critics of Free Trade have all of a sudden become strong defenders of it, and highly critical of any kind of trade policy intervention. If Trump is against free trade, then it must be good. On top of that, the fear of inflation -- always a recurrent paranoia among more conservative policy makers -- has been exacerbated by the perception that tariffs will cause stagflation, and has led to a concern that Jerome Powell, the Federal Reserve (Fed) chairman, might be fired by Trump, even if that is more complicated than firing the Commissioner of the Bureau of Labor Statics (BLS). This, in turn, has led to some strong defense, by liberals and progressives, of an independent Fed.
Free trade and rule based monetary policy (at least not the Gold Standard) are back on the agenda. I should say many liberals, with strong influence among the establishment of the Democratic Party, are also not far from defending some degree of austerity after what they perceive as the excesses of Biden's fiscal policy. In that case, it would be a return to the policy consensus of the Victorian era, free trade, rule based monetary policy, and fiscal discipline. A setback, given that the profession was, not long ago, rethinking the so-called New Consensus in macroeconomics, and was moving away from more rigid inflation targeting, with the Fed adopting a more flexible approach, and more acceptance that persistent deficits and even a higher level of debt were not unsustainable.
It is clear that the tariffs will not bring back any significant number of manufacturing jobs back to the US (a longer discussion here; bottom line, wages are still high in the US, and production will shift to other places), but it is also true that trade policies, together with government procurement policies do play a strategic role in promoting technological innovation and economic growth. But the arguments have gone considerably beyond that. On the international arena, the paranoid style in economic policy advising suggests that the tariffs will bring the end of US hegemony, not just some adjustments on supply chains. It will bring a run against the dollar and dollar denominated assets. If it needs repeating, there is no risk to dollar hegemony, even if China has challenged US hegemony in some crucial sectors.
The next exaggerated fear is that tariffs will bring stagflation. On that, as I have discussed here (and here for Pandemic fears, that proved unfounded, notwithstanding Larry Summers' predictions; note that he blames Biden, and not pandemic supply-side shock for the 2022 inflation bout*), the risk of inflation, let alone high inflation, is relatively moderate. Sure enough tariffs will have some impact on the price level, but as much as the snags on the supply chain during the pandemic, this would translate only as a moderate and transitory shock, that will vanish fast. Actually, since the economy is slowing down, and wage bargaining has been eroded even further (on top of that with the weakening of the National Labor Relations Board), chances of inflation acceleration should take a back seat.
The risk of a recession does NOT come from the possible supply-chain problems that tariffs could cause, nor from the uncertainty (that vague and lazy way of saying that anything could happen; the uncertainty fairy), and neither from a possible profit squeeze that would lead to declining investment. It is actually, as I noted recently, the persistent of relatively high interest rates. Trump is NOT incorrect in criticizing Powell on this issue (the form might be wrong, but on substance he is correct). The housing market is affected, and that will have an impact on consumption, and that might cause a recession.
Further, many authors that used to correctly see the fiscal problems, at least temporarily, as secondary, are now concerned with the sustainability of US debt in domestic currency. Something that is absolutely irrelevant even if all three credit agencies have downgraded US public debt (that's material for another post).
Faced with Trump's economics agenda progressives have retreated from the policies that, at least on a conceptual level, were being developed after the 2008-9 financial crisis, policies that endorsed fiscal activism, unconventional monetary policy, and a healthy rethinking of industrial and trade policy (the latter mostly after Trump's first election, and Biden's so-called New Washington Consensus). Not only the notion is that fiscal policy was excessively lax, causing inflation, that monetary policy must remain contractionary, to avoid the inflationary pressures of the tariffs, but also that free trade and is central for US hegemony.
Edward Luce, FT columnist (and former speechwriter for Summers), author of The Retreat of Liberalism (a book that equates free markets and Western democracy with development) now tells us that the main sin of liberalism (which should be taken here in the American sense of progressivism, and not libertarian free market dogma) is intolerance. The excessive reliance on science during the pandemic, and the lack of free speech in academia, the press, and society at large. He sees that as a return to the Victorian era. In his words:
"... today’s liberal establishment looks more like a conservative one. Educated elites confect orthodoxy on what we should say and do. The resemblance to high Victorianism is more than passing. Victorians regulated manners and etiquette. They also dreaded the mob."
He is not completely wrong. The current liberal establishment, of which he is a member, resembles the Victorians, but it is in the renewed defense of an outdated economic policy consensus, free trade, hard money, and sound finance.
* In this interview Summers says: "I felt that the Biden administration was failing to pay attention to fairly elementary economic arithmetic with respect to the excessive stimulus that it launched in response to Covid. But in that case there was a logic in terms of insurance, adding to confidence and promoting employment. That was a policy with both benefits and costs, where I felt—and I think it has turned out this way—the costs exceeded the benefits. Here [Trump's policies] it seems like it’s almost all cost with very little benefit."
Saturday, November 25, 2023
Was Keynes a Liberal or a Socialist?
My old Will Lyons Lecture at Franklin & Marshall College in the Spring of 2021 is now a working paper. Prof. Lyons was a Bucknell Graduate, and a professor at F&M. The topic was based on the, at that time, recent reading of Jim Crotty's book. From the abstract:
Right-wing critics of Keynes have often suggested that he was a socialist. His policy proposals were very often described as a slippery slope that would lead society into a totalitarian nightmare. Alternatively, from the left, Keynes was often seen as a reformist that intended to preserve the essence of capitalism. His reforms were mere window dressing on an exploitative system. The scholarship on Keynes also remained divided. However, in the last few decades a more robust position in favor of Keynes’ socialist affiliation was developed, particularly in the careful scholarship by Rod O’Donnell and James Crotty. This paper suggests that while Keynes was a pragmatist willing to experiment in economic policy, and fully aware of the need to transform and transcend laissez-faire capitalism, he remained a liberal, in particular because Labourites, and most socialists, remained conservative in their economic policy outlook. Keynes was a
revolutionary in economic theory, but a moderate in his politics.
Read paper here.
Sunday, May 23, 2021
Was Keynes a Liberal or a Socialist?
A shorter version at the ISET conference of my Will Lyons Lecture at Franklin & Marshall. And yes, I think Harrod and Skidelsky were right (not Crotty and O'Donnell). He was definitely an Asquith Liberal.
Saturday, September 13, 2014
How Keynesianism became a dirty word: not Hayek, the New Deal is the real cause
Noah Smith, now writing regularly for Bloomberg, had a piece on this subject. There are a few good points on how New Keynesians are really followers of Friedman, something Mankiw admitted long ago, and how everybody including conservative economists (meaning GOP economists like John Taylor and Ben Bernanke) are New Keynesians (these would be the potty trained GOP economists, not your supply-side fringe economists like Arthur Laffer). Note that this is essentially correct as pointed out here before, since New Keynesians accept fully Friedman's notion of a natural rate of unemployment, while Keynes explicitly said he wanted to reject the twin concept of a natural rate of interest.
Noah also suggests that Keynes only wanted stabilization policies, and no redistributive policies, which is more open to debate. Keynes was certainly a moderate reformer trying to save capitalism from itself, and was no fan of the Soviet experiment. On the other hand, he was an Asquith liberal, meaning concerned with the expansion of the welfare system, and knew that laissez-faire, if it had advantages in the past, was essentially dead.
In the General Theory (GT) he famously starts chapter 24, on his social philosophy, with the idea that: "the outstanding faults of the economic society in which we live are its failure to provide for full employment and its arbitrary and inequitable distribution of wealth and incomes." That is, income distribution is squarely in the middle of his preoccupations, and the socialization of investment at the center of his solution (let alone the euthanasia of the rentier). Using public investment, and one would imagine taxes, to deal with employment and income distribution, plus compressing the remuneration of rentiers, and keeping low rates of interest to expand the safety net, are not simply stabilization policies.
On the main topic of his piece, however, Noah is simply wrong. He argues that the reason why: "people think Keynesianism is socialism-lite [is] the fault of Keynes’s main intellectual opponent, Friedrich Hayek." First, while it's true that Keynes and Hayek had a few debates in the 1930s (but the key Keynesian author in these debates was actually Sraffa, not Keynes), prompted by Lionel Robbins plan to make the London School of Economics (LSE) an alternative to Cambridge, it is preposterous to say that Hayek was the main intellectual opponent of Keynes. In the GT, it was his own teacher Pigou, and the Marshallian tradition in Cambridge that Keynes was battling. In his personal debates Robertson was certainly more relevant than almost any other conventional (Marshallian) economist. Hayek was irrelevant.
Second, Hayek basically vanished, literally, after the 1940s only to reaper in the 1970s as a result of his dubious "Nobel"/Bank of Sweden's prize (see Sissela Bok's, Myrdal's daughter, story on that topic). By that time Keynes and Keynesianism were already dirty words. Early on Keynesian ideas were associated, fairly or not, with Roosevelt and the New Deal in the US, and then to the war coalition government in the UK, the Beveridge Report and the post-war Labour reforms. Keynesian economists were in many cases persecuted, like Lauchlin Currie, the first economist to work inside the White House, and one of the early Keynesians. But by the 1950s and 1960s (particularly after the Kennedy administration) one kind of Keynesianism was dominant anyway (the Kennedy tax cut and the economists working for his administration are the symbol of the dominance of Keynesian ideas).
So you ask why indeed did Keynesianism become a dirty word? Simply because even if Keynes had differences with Roosevelt (FDR was actually a sound finance guy) and with Labour, his ideas did provide the intellectual basis for New Deal policies, particularly after the 1937-38 recession, and for the expansion of the Welfare State in general. The economists that where against these policies by the 1940s were in the minority. Mont Pelerin is, if anything, prove of their sheer irrelevance. Friedman years later would complain about how ostracized he was (but less than Hayek, since he accepted the ISLM/Phillips curve apparatus of the Neoclassical Synthesis Keynesians; and that's why New Keynesians, who are really followers of Friedman, can say they are Keynesian, by the way). Liberalism, in the US sense of the word, was at its height. But the rise of conservatism (Goldwater was a joke back then) eventually transformed liberalism into a dirty word (that's why we use progressive now rather than liberal).
Hayek was resuscitated very much like conservative ideas. By the big bucks of business leaders and their think tanks that were against the New Deal. The rise of Hayek or of his renewed respectability results from the same forces that explain why Keynesianism and the New Deal kind of welfare policies fell in disrepute, to the point that Niall Ferguson could say that Keynesianism was flawed because Keynes was childless and gay. Oh well.
PS: In fact, the title of this blog is related to the view that Keynesianism is a dirty word, and that some people (Galbraith) unashamedly teach naked Keynesianism to innocent college kids. For more see here.

